Anthony Casuccio breathes new life into a cult classic with 'Am I Wrong'

Buffalo’s acclaimed producer and musician Anthony Casuccio steps into uncharted territory with his first official cover of 'Am I Wrong', originally penned by Richard and Tim Butler for Love Spit Love. Rather than simply echoing the cult classic, Casuccio infuses the track with his own warmth and ingenuity, creating a version that feels both reverent and distinctly his own.

From the opening notes, Casuccio’s meticulous production shines through in every layer, blending lush strings, inventive synth bass, and a subtly modernised rhythm section. Tyler Casuccio, Anthony’s 16-year-old son, programs drums that are both precise and playful, injecting a youthful energy that complements the song’s introspective undertones. Kent Weber’s bass lines add a grounded groove that anchors the arrangement, while longtime collaborator Mike Rieman’s string contributions elevate the track with cinematic richness, creating a texture that feels expansive yet intimately connected.

Vocally, he takes a bold approach. Attempting to channel Richard Butler’s distinctive timbre, a gamble that pays off, adding a raw, human quality to the performance. The result is a voice that balances homage with vulnerability, breathing new emotional resonance into lyrics that have captivated listeners for decades.

What sets this rendition apart is its careful balance of nostalgia and reinvention. While fans of Love Spit Love will recognise the song’s familiar melodic contours, Casuccio’s subtle innovations give it a contemporary pulse without overshadowing the original’s emotional core. The production feels effortless, yet every choice speaks to the artist's seasoned ear and deep understanding of musical storytelling.

'Am I Wrong' is a celebration of Buffalo’s musical community, and a masterclass in how a familiar song can feel newly alive. Anthony Casuccio proves that honouring a classic can still be done with care, heart, and a touch of genius.